Star Trek has been very important to me for the vast majority of my life. As a little kid, I remember my grandmother watching the show and the movies now and then. I vaguely remember in 1987 when I started seeing commercials for Star Trek: The Next Generation. Somehow I even ended up with a sticker of Commander William Riker on my desk, even though I had no idea who he was.
It wasn’t until December of 1991 when my love for Star Trek truly kicked in. About a month earlier, my grandmother said she wanted to watch an episode of the “new” Star Trek show because Spock was going to be in it. That excited me – I knew who Spock was, sort of. I remembered seeing him. Up until that point some part of me resented the idea that there was a new Star Trek without Kirk, even though I hadn’t really seen much of it. It was just the concept. So we watched Unification. I had no clue what the heck was going on, mind you, but it seemed okay.
I don’t know if my grandmother said something to my dad about it, but a month later, he took me to see Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country in theaters. I knew enough about Star Trek to understand that this was supposed to be the final movie, so it felt like a big deal. Let me tell you, from the opening moments of Cliff Eidelman’s epic score, which dramatically built up to a huge explosion, to Kirk’s beautifully delivered final course setting (Second star to the right, and straight on ‘til morning… sniff…) I was hooked. There was action! Mystery! Aliens! Epic starship battles! Political drama! And a strong, positive message about letting go of hatred and prejudice! And it all felt so smart! The film flowed seamlessly, the story made sense. The characters were intelligent and did things that made sense. It had kind of a Star Wars vibe, but it felt so much more mature and polished and intelligent. At that moment, Star Trek became my obsession.
For the rest of that winter, between my dad and my grandmother, I ate up everything I could that was Star Trek. We watched all five previous movies, in order. I started watching Star Trek: The Next Generation with my grandmother. It became a weekly ritual. And it was on five nights per night in syndication by that point, so I was able to immerse myself quickly.
I also found a friend of mine at my new private school who was a fan, and it went a long way towards cementing that friendship (we are still friends to this day, and still love our Trek). I finally started catching episodes of original Trek late at night on, I think, the SciFi channel (before they changed their branding to the idiotic SyFy).
I admit to having seen most episodes of the actual, original canon of Star Trek (that is to say, TOS, TNG, DS9, VOY, and ENT; anything past those and their movies are not part of the original Trek canon, but made under a completely different license…and also, they suck), but I can’t say I’ve seen them all. Especially when it comes to the classic series, I believe there are possibly dozens of episodes I’ve missed.
Given that we have been bereft of good Star Trek for a very, very long time, I figured maybe it’s time to revisit the classics. I’ve acquired the original series on Bluray, complete with restored visual effects. I’ll be watching them as-presented, meaning going by the original airdates and not including the original pilot episode, The Cage. I’m not going to do an in-depth review of each, but I’ll certainly share my thoughts and anecdotes in some kind of loosely organized format. There’s so much Trek out there to watch, and I am not in a particular hurry, so some weeks I may watch an episode every night and some, I may not. We’ll see how it all goes.
The Man Trap
Originally Aired: September 8th, 1966
Series Premiere
Brief Summary
The Enterprise travels to M-113 to bring supplies to and conduct medical exams on a Federation doctor and his wife. This wife happens to be an ex-lover of Doctor McCoy, and appears to be completely untouched by age when McCoy sees her. Yet strangely, Kirk and the first-ever redshirt of the series (I know, it’s not red) see Nancy differently. Kirk sees her as a little older, while our doomed redshirt sees her as a gorgeouss blond. Soon after, the redshirt ends up dead and we have our very first Star Trek mystery on our hands. Kirk and the crew must figure out what most of the audience works out early on, that Nancy is some kind of alien who needs constant salt and can change her form to appear differently to different people. The conclusion finds the doctor and “Nancy” both dead, along with a few more crew members of the Enterprise.
Episode Info
While this actually the sixth episode produced, it ended up being the first one that aired. My research indicates this was a simple process of elimination; of all the completed episodes, it seemed to offer the best balance of intelligence and action, with a “proper” alien menace. Oddly enough, the actual pilot episode (the one that sold the series), Where No Man Has Gone Before, was considered “too expository” to launch the series. I don’t know if I agree with that personally, but we’ll touch on that when I get to it.
Also, a fun note: even though Trek belonged to NBC at the time, it was the Canadian network CTV that actually aired the very first episode of Star Trek; they aired this episode two days earlier on September 6th, 1966.
My Musings & Observations
While I do try to watch these as if I’d never seen them before, I can’t help but think what a humble and unremarkable beginning it is for characters that would become so iconic and important to so many. I mean, Uhura’s first scene is her basically trying to bait Spock into telling her how pretty she is. It was a fun moment, and a good demonstration of Spock’s detached logic.
Yeoman Rand is kind of treated like a piece of meat in this episode, with half a dozen crewman ogling her and tripping over themselves around her. I can’t blame them, Grace Lee Whitney is absolutely stunning and Rand is written as a smart, self-assured character who seems just as likely to punch these guys as toy with them. Episode one and we’re already breaking new ground. (Though I can hear the 2020 social justice mob bitching about a dozen things already.)
The story was interesting, and I can imagine as a child who hadn’t seen anything like it before being captivated by the weird alien monster.
Kirk comes across as very charming even in this first outing, teasing McCoy about seeing his ex-girlfriend by suggesting he bring her “flowers” (a clump of weeds, since that’s all the vegetation on the planet, it seems).
I liked how they tried to tie in the events here with real science (i.e. the biological need for salt and what might happen if we lose too much). As someone who does keto, I can absolutely attest to the importance of this electrolyte!
This was a fun outing, and one of the many episodes I had never seen before. It felt strange to me that this was the first episode of the series to air, since it seems to make some assumptions about the characters, but this was a different time. Episodic television was seen as more of an “adventure of the week” kind of thing, without the overall story arcs and drama. You could pick up almost any episode of Star Trek without having seen any other episodes and it would still make sense. So really it’s just un-learning what I’ve learned about how television works today.
That scene where Kirk was eating on the bridge – what the heck was on his plate? It looked like he was eating Lego bricks.
I liked how hard Kirk took the first death. He really wanted to find out what happened, he took the loss personally. It seemed the subsequent deaths were less significant to him, though. I understand the focus here was the action and the story, not the emotional reactions of the crew. It’s a problem that, in my mind, plagues Star Trek throughout all of its forms to some degree. Because they don’t want to get too bogged down in weighty emotions, they gloss over most redshirt deaths. They knew the risks, we expect this to happen, etc. etc. When a major crew member dies (which does not happen on television until TNG), that becomes a bigger deal. And when DS9 gets here with its war arc, it becomes a very big deal. So it was odd to see those two extremes in this same episode. Typically, redshirts die to establish the seriousness of the situation. But if no one on the Enterprise seems to care when they die, why should the audience. So it kind of defeats the purpose a bit, in my opinion.